Mafia: The Holy Grail (Game Over - SK Wins!)

[shiznak]

All I have to say is, if I had any sort of role in this game.

 

I wouldn’t be posting these nonsensical posts.

 

Just a regular square……I mean squire, peeps.

[Time Lord]

Just now, Zfetch said:

Unvote; Vote Ilunga

Safer bet

I think he needs to be given a chance to explain himself because he might be the [redacted]

[Zfetch]

I believe Shiznak at this time and find any votes against him as a very easy way to misguide the vote

[Time Lord]

3 minutes ago, J-23 said:

Lucky

 

Aladeen now TP lean no way he and SS are teammates 

How would lucky and SS be teammates?

[Zfetch]

Just now, Time Lord said:

I think he needs to be given a chance to explain himself because he might be the [redacted]

That's fair, in which case he needs to come out confirm MR LL and whoever he investigated round 3

[Zfetch]

There's 16 people left and likely 5 mafia (4 left). Based on the theory and convention that ideal # of mafia is sqrt(players).

 

One wrong vig kill and lynch will put us in a bad, potentially unrecoverable spot. Anyone that knows me knows I often advocate the sheriff coming out r3ish and will say so bluntly. The power to clear 2-3 people and reduce the odds of us being in a hole too deep to dig out of is the favorable play IMO even if it means the loss of one key figure. 

[Zfetch]

Plus I could just watch over said sheriff tehe

[Zfetch]

They likely can't roleblock me two rounds in a row so it is critical for me to put this watch in effective use, plus I doubt the team would kill me when there are bigger fish to fry right now

[Time Lord]

2 minutes ago, Zfetch said:

Plus I could just watch over said sheriff tehe

But what if the sheriff waits another round and you watch them next round and we get 2 more investigations instead of 1

[Zfetch]

Just now, Time Lord said:

But what if the sheriff waits another round and you watch them next round and we get 2 more investigations instead of 1

I probably get roleblocked next round and sheriff might get killed this round especially if I outed Ilunga so no that doesn't make a whole lot of sense imo

[luckylager]

Wow J23 legit on crack or mafia. No in between

[Sharpshooter]

3 hours ago, Zfetch said:

From memory SS is the type of guy who thinks he’s smarter than he is so he for sure threw one of his teammates under the bus

[Zfetch]

It's possible there is a lackey in this game since iirc they have roleblocking ability.

 

If Ilunga says he is sheriff, we will know the mafia will target him this round, Ilduce next round, roleblock me next round, maybe roleblock Ilduce this round.

 

Us being able to strongly infer what they will do will place us in a good position to make the moves we need to make as TP core.

Now is the time to turn it on into overdrive. 

[Aladeen]

That plan is all depended on fetch actually being town and not just special hunting. I think sheriff should wait before revealing. I am not 100% sold on watcher and tracker both being town roles. 
 

even if fetch is not mafia there is still 3p which we know nothing besides likely being 2 more of them. Sheriff is necessary to find not just mafia but figure out all the scum. 

[Zfetch]

Sheriff waiting is a horrible idea if Ilunga isn't mafia since they will have narrowed him down to doc or sheriff and will be in a better position.

 

Your skepticism Aladeen reflects towny but I don't like the suboptimal line of thinking both you and TL are exhibiting. Whose to say if the sheriff comes out that the doc wouldn't as well and then I watch over the sheriff and reveal a ton of more information or at the very least we get one more round?

 

This is simpleton thinking from the two of you, though I am not surprised by Aladeen since he couldn't do the very basic task of deducing I was watcher earlier 

[Aladeen]

Fook right off with pushing for sheriff to come out you turd of a primate. Even if you are town your plan sucks donkey ballz coated in ghost pepper sauce. 
 

Everything you said about SS is true for you. If we need someone to masturbate and throw feces we can defer to your expertise fetch.  

[J-23]

17 minutes ago, Time Lord said:

How would lucky and SS be teammates?

I didn’t read R3 yet tbh looking at R2 SS posts

[Time Lord]

5 minutes ago, Zfetch said:

I probably get roleblocked next round and sheriff might get killed this round especially if I outed Ilunga so no that doesn't make a whole lot of sense imo

True the roleblocking is probably a compelling enough point...

 

16 players, 2 confirmed TP (ilduce and Zfetch)

Let's say the sheriff comes out and gives us 3 TP, then we're at 6 confirmed TP and 10 unknowns

But we can probably clear at least 2 people by using our brains (I say lucky and AT), so 8 unknowns

Then let's say we lynch incorrectly and vig kill incorrectly for 2 straight days, the game is still going (assuming 4 mafia are left), and we'll have 4 unknowns left..

 

So yeah maybe we can win the game if the sheriff comes out

 

[Zfetch]

Just now, Aladeen said:

Fook right off with pushing for sheriff to come out you turd of a primate. Even if you are town your plan sucks donkey ballz coated in ghost pepper sauce. 
 

Everything you said about SS is true for you. If we need someone to masturbate and throw feces we can defer to your expertise fetch.  

I can't take you seriously based on your retardation earlier being unable to deduce what one possible role I could have been claiming

[Master Radishes]

Let the Sheriff decide, should one exist (tracker is pretty sheriff-esque and having both feels unfair for the mafia). They might've copped a dead town so the numbers don't work as well as you guys are hoping.