Mafia: The Game [Underground] --- GAME OVER, SIGN-UP IN NEW TOPIC

[Aladeen]

Hoping MR will give analysis soon, I have no idea who to vote for this round.

[Master Radishes]

Geez guys, is there a rule that MR is the only one allowed to provide analysis?

Don't wait on me - share your own thoughts! Your opinions are all as equally valid as mine.

[Kryten]

OK MR. Well after reviewing the thread and reading some of the posts by Intoewsables I am going to Vote Apples . Intoewsables, a mafia, came to Apple's defence twice early in the first round. Apples has also been unusually quiet and I believe it is because he is a mafia this game trying to avoid the limelight that shone on him last game. As usual this is open to change if someone has a better claim or idea.

[Drouin]

Geez guys, is there a rule that MR is the only one allowed to provide analysis?

Don't wait on me - share your own thoughts! Your opinions are all as equally valid as mine.

[Drouin]

OK MR. Well after reviewing the thread and reading some of the posts by Intoewsables I am going to Vote Apples . Intoewsables, a mafia, came to Apple's defence twice early in the first round. Apples has also been unusually quiet and I believe it is because he is a mafia this game trying to avoid the limelight that shone on him last game. As usual this is open to change if someone has a better claim or idea.

[Go Faulk Yourself]

Hoping MR will give analysis soon, I have no idea who to vote for this round.

[Drouin]

Sheriff, i'm a TP.

Investigate me if you'd like then once you know for sure, PM me.

[dKs89]

Honestly I have equal suspicion for everyone, but I need to vote or else I'll be god-killed. I'll target one of the quieter players, and

VOTE FEDERER for now, but this is very open to change.

[Go Faulk Yourself]

Sheriff, i'm a TP.

Investigate me if you'd like then once you know for sure, PM me.

[King Heffy]

Although I suspect they'll make another attempt on JE14 tonight due to him being the only confirmed TP. Doc, you know what to do.

[King Heffy]

I'd ask the sheriff to investigate me as well, but it's still difficult for the sheriff to prove he is infact the real sheriff.

[Aladeen]

I don't think we should all hold our breath for MR's analysis post to decide on who to vote for. I also don't fully trust MR yet with this whole sheriff thing. It could easily be a setup and he could be playing on the mafia's end and trying to get us to lynch TP by gaining our trust and leading us with said analysis.

Although, I'd like to believe he is infact a TP, and has been investigated by the sheriff.

If the sheriff is listening, if you haven't investigated MR yet, you need to find a way to get the TP the truth, someone to speak for you on your behalf, someone like JE14 who should be considered the likeliest of confirmed TP's now since the mafia tried to kill him in round 1 and failed at the hands of the lackey.

[Master Radishes]

That's the truth of the matter, especially in a kingpin game. If we rely as much on the sheriff this game as we did last time we're gonners.

[Master Radishes]

I also don't fully trust MR yet with this whole sheriff thing. It could easily be a setup and he could be playing on the mafia's end and trying to get us to lynch TP by gaining our trust and leading us with said analysis.

[Master Radishes]

Unvote Reigning Champ

I'll re-cast a vote later, when I've had a chance to look over things.

[Go Faulk Yourself]

From looking at the last few pages, this is what I have gathered.

Playing in previous games with Alchemy Time, he is usually very vocal. I understand that people change their habits when given different roles, when Alchemy was the SK, he was very vocal and went all the way to the end of the game hiding as the SK before dying. When I was Mafia with him, most of his chat went through the PM, he was only overly-vocal when Apples accused him of being Mafia along with Lemons, in which, after the game, we all knew he was, so up to that point, he wasn't that vocal. Take this for what you will.

Hodor, who I have not seen play this game before, but might have in the past, is avoiding most of what's going on in the game so far. She is talking within the thread, but not really referring to posts relating to the game, might be because she is trying to get a feel for the game, or just going through the PM's with mafia and trying to blend in without being noticed.

Susraiders, I haven't seen anything from him yet.

Beluga Whale posted and basically abstained his vote the first round, but from how I know Beluga, when he is Mafia, from what I've seen, he tries to blend in the game and not really make an impact. When he ousted me as being a fake sheriff a few games back, he was very vocal in having me killed, that was of course when he was a Special TP, so do take this analysis with a grain of salt.

Note I've never done this whole "Analysis" before, so don't be too swayed by my words.

[Peaches]

OK MR. Well after reviewing the thread and reading some of the posts by Intoewsables I am going to Vote Apples . Intoewsables, a mafia, came to Apple's defence twice early in the first round. Apples has also been unusually quiet and I believe it is because he is a mafia this game trying to avoid the limelight that shone on him last game. As usual this is open to change if someone has a better claim or idea.

[Go Faulk Yourself]

My analysis post also is for future reference to keep tabs on players as the game goes on, as Apples seems like the most logical person to vote for this round.

Vote Apples

[King Heffy]

My analysis post also is for future reference to keep tabs on players as the game goes on, as Apples seems like the most logical person to vote for this round.

Vote Apples

[Beluga Whale]

OK MR. Well after reviewing the thread and reading some of the posts by Intoewsables I am going to Vote Apples . Intoewsables, a mafia, came to Apple's defence twice early in the first round. Apples has also been unusually quiet and I believe it is because he is a mafia this game trying to avoid the limelight that shone on him last game. As usual this is open to change if someone has a better claim or idea.