Mafia: The Holy Grail (Game Over - SK Wins!)

[Blue Jay 22]

Attention Players:

 

Round 4 has now begun. Nightfall will be tomorrow at 9:00PM PCT. All actions and votes must be submitted by then. If you read this message and did not vote last round, you better do so this round. Good luck!

 

1. 

2. @luckylager

3. 

4. @Ilunga

5. @ilduce39

6. @Aladeen

7. @Zfetch

8. @Intoewsables

9. @AngryElf

10. @Master Radishes

11. @Alchemy Time

12. @shiznak

13. @Where's Wellwood

14. @Time Lord

15. 

16. @DarthMelvin

17. @thejazz97

18. 

19. 

20. @Snake Doctor

21. 

22. @J-23

23. 

24. 

[Master Radishes]

Ilduce has:

-targeted two slots we wouldn't be able to solve on our own due to low posting

-took himself out of the PoE after being a likely elimination target

-nailed a mafia goon with a bit of a hero shot

 

How to Play as Vig 101

[Master Radishes]

Also I'm not the tracker, but Lucky is cleared for seeing the softs and thinking I am.

 

I was going to let it go but since Tanev flipped as Tracker there's no point.

 

 

[Master Radishes]

By the way, make sure you guys watch 'The Traitors' when it comes out in Canada. It's Mafia in TV form.

 

The Aussie version is my favourite. Hopefully the Canadian version is okay too.

[Master Radishes]

Also,

  

34 minutes ago, shiznak said:

Gg boys.
 

Easy win.

What do I make of this shiznak?

[Master Radishes]

Doing this for myself but also if it helps anyone then here you go:

 

Start of game: https://forum.canucks.com/topic/409104-mafia-the-holy-grail-game-on/page/6/#comment-16940425

Night 1 report: https://forum.canucks.com/topic/409104-mafia-the-holy-grail-game-on/page/21/#comment-16940896

Night 2 report: https://forum.canucks.com/topic/409104-mafia-the-holy-grail-game-on/page/37/#comment-16941267

Night 3 report: https://forum.canucks.com/topic/409104-mafia-the-holy-grail-game-on/page/54/#comment-16941638

 

[Blue Jay 22]

3 minutes ago, Master Radishes said:

Doing this for myself but also if it helps anyone then here you go:

 

 

 

Start of game: https://forum.canucks.com/topic/409104-mafia-the-holy-grail-game-on/page/6/#comment-16940425

 

Night 1 report: https://forum.canucks.com/topic/409104-mafia-the-holy-grail-game-on/page/21/#comment-16940896

 

Night 2 report: https://forum.canucks.com/topic/409104-mafia-the-holy-grail-game-on/page/37/#comment-16941267

 

Night 3 report: https://forum.canucks.com/topic/409104-mafia-the-holy-grail-game-on/page/54/#comment-16941638

 

 

 

This has now been made into a game map for all that can be found on page 1

[Master Radishes]

SS barely posted D1 and didn't vote.

 

His first serious post came in D2:

 

On 9/22/2023 at 6:55 PM, Sharpshooter said:

Again apologies to all. 
 

Here’s a couple thoughts I had reading back. 
 

- I can’t recall SD being so cozy with me ever and posting fluff, zeros and ones stuff. Not sure why he was onto BW as well. Not sure why he’s voting for LL, who’s played a pretty straight town game thus far, imo. 
 

- NIK, seems like he’s in his town meta. Not posting crazy but controlled reactions about things that don’t make sense to him. I don’t agree with Al or TL about voting NIK right now. Lewt has slanked/less active in the past as he is now and come back as red flip. Not saying he is, but it’s been done before by him. 
 

- Slankers. FFS! Aren’t I always saying to vote them first? Why don’t you people listen to me?

 

- Lewt going out there and being the first in Qwags without a good reason didn’t make sense. 
 

- MR’s posts came back totally genuine to me. But, that doesn’t necessarily make him town. Nostalgia could be scum cover by making people get the warm and fuzzies. Not sure he would do a self vote as scum though. That’s a big gamble, if people think he’s playing games and doing it in order to not vote him. For now, he’s leaning town to me. 
 

 

-Al is active and playing it pretty straight in his posts and responses. Run of the mill Al imo. Lean town. 
 

- BK, slanking. Come on man! 
 

- Zfetch seems towny to me so far. 
 

- Haven’t played with Shiz so I don’t know how he plays. 
 

If I’ve forgotten anyone then they at fall into the slanker category. 

 

 

[Master Radishes]

Possible things:

 

-SS gives a fair few words to SD but goes nowhere with the read - contrast with his read on NIK which has as many words but at least arrives at a conclusion. (Which is also what he does with his read on me, for comparison.)

-Shades Lewt twice - he doesn't do that with anyone else in this post but worth noting what SS is going for if I come across future posts

-Why include that comment on shiznak? It's not like he commented on everyone else.

 

Think every other comment is fairly NAI.

[Master Radishes]

On 9/22/2023 at 8:25 PM, naslund.is.king said:

I'm not buying SS this game

Seems fake. 

 

I wonder if it's SS + slankers. SS takes on scum captain role and eliminates a threat to himself, and spends the game going 'grrr slankers!' for future cred if any flip.

[Master Radishes]

On 9/20/2023 at 4:25 PM, Snake Doctor said:

Yes let’s go town. Sharp Shooter and Snake doctor on the same team. Epic finish.

  

On 9/22/2023 at 8:45 PM, Master Radishes said:

I say we just call this early post TMI and kill Snake Doctor.

 

Vote Snake Doctor

 

LOL imagine if I called it

[Ilunga]

2 minutes ago, Master Radishes said:

 

I wonder if it's SS + slankers. SS takes on scum captain role and eliminates a threat to himself, and spends the game going 'grrr slankers!' for future cred if any flip.

So are you staying that most of all of the scum team are slanking ?

[Ilunga]

Stating 

[Master Radishes]

Just now, Ilunga said:

So are you staying that most of all of the scum team are slanking ?

Just speculating. It feels like it could fit the NIK kill + general gamestate. I find a fair few of the more active posters towny.

 

Not saying this is a sure thing.

[Master Radishes]

Someone remind me later that there are some things on page 25-27ish that might be AI regarding what SS says about people or what people say about SS.

 

Don't want to clog the thread up with more speculation right now, though.

 

[Ilunga]

1 minute ago, Master Radishes said:

Just speculating. It feels like it could fit the NIK kill + general gamestate. I find a fair few of the more active posters towny.

 

Not saying this is a sure thing.

So do you have any other takes from this last nightfall ?

After last game, every vote I screwed up, my confidence in reading people is low.

[Master Radishes]

Not quoting all posts because not-clogging-up-thread and whatnot. I'm reading D2 in the mid-20s page range.

 

 

SS and SD have enough back and forth that maybe they're not teammates? Mafia partners tend to be more likely to avoid too much convo in thread because something something distancing.

 

Intoewsables dances around suspicion on SS a fair bit. I don't think it's hard enough to be not paired, and might just be Toewsy looking for a safe place to distance. But SS doesn't really acknowledge it so if so it's not coordinated. Maybe Toews just had a good ping.

 

There are a couple little things that make me go 'hmm' at Aladeen, but I don't want to start that again just yet. Might be nothing.

[Master Radishes]

Made it end of D2 on a skim thru for SS' posts. He was gone EoD so a NIK kill still makes sense from him specifically.

 

Gotta stop now though.

[Master Radishes]

On 9/22/2023 at 5:10 AM, Blue Jay 22 said:

 

Final Round 1 Vote Count:

 

Qwags (4) - Lewitelli, Boknows, Time Lord, Aladeen

Snake Doctor (3) - Beluga Whale, Ilunga, Alchemy Time

Naslund.is.King (2) - J23, luckylager

Intoews (2) - Jazz, Zfetch

Time Lord (1) - Tanev

Aladeen (1) - Ilduce

Beluga Whale (1) - Snake Doctor

Master Radishes (1) - Shiznak

Sharpshooter (1) - NIK

 

Extend (3) - Where's Wellwood, Intoews, Master Radishes

 

No Vote (5) - Qwags, Falcon, Porscha, SS, Coconuts

 

Just leaving it here to stare at. Probably too early to mean much. Perhaps if SD was mafia we'd see more players on the top wagons? Like a vote spread so wide indicates mafia weren't in trouble so people didn't worry about moving votes? But yeah, too early to say for sure.

 

Okay bye.

[Time Lord]

32 minutes ago, Master Radishes said:

Possible things:

 

-SS gives a fair few words to SD but goes nowhere with the read - contrast with his read on NIK which has as many words but at least arrives at a conclusion. (Which is also what he does with his read on me, for comparison.)

-Shades Lewt twice - he doesn't do that with anyone else in this post but worth noting what SS is going for if I come across future posts

-Why include that comment on shiznak? It's not like he commented on everyone else.

 

Think every other comment is fairly NAI.

Yeah I quickly read through that and the comment on shiznak sticks out like a sore thumb. I think they’re teammates