Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

[Report] Canucks fire Jim Benning, name Stan Smyl as interim GM

Rate this topic


-Vintage Canuck-

Recommended Posts

1 minute ago, King Heffy said:

Gillis couldn't even draft NHLers after the first round, and even then he struggled.  Benning is gone for a reason,. but it would be insane to replace him with the incompetent moron he replaced.

Agree Jensen Gaunce Sauve the mighty Hodgson wow no thanks. If Gilly comes back he will bring back the old scouting group and we will be repeating our horrible drafting. At least JB drafts were able to be Nhlers.

  • Cheers 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, BlakeQuinnAndEggs said:

He added the right pieces to push us over the edge. Lots of things were done behind the scenes to improve culture and desirability to play here. He made the right decisions to re sign the twins to great deals where a lot of rumblings that they would walk.

 

His drafting was poor but he drafted late most of the time and he got us Horvat.

 

Bennings drafting is over rated. Drafting top 5 /top 10 all the time you should have good players.

 

Besides Demko, Boeser, and Hoglander who else is a great late pick? After 8 years a few of those are expected.

 

JB wore out his welcome and I was a supporter for years up until Last season.

 

Gillis fault was creating a goalie controversy and hiring Torts.

 

Anyway I dont want him to be our next GM I just think ya sure JB has acquired a lot of good young pieces but that's expected when you rebuild for 8 years. Way too many mistakes. Losing sucks

At least in NHL/AHL Forsling, Gaudette.

 

Jensen, Gaunce where they at

Edited by PositionOfPower
Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, tas said:

 

who do you propose?

McPhee rumors are there plus he had past working relationship with Bruce for Caps.

 

Lombardi that made the Kings champions but not sure if he wants to work for Aqua.

 

Theres Futa AGM for Lombardi for the Kings back then. Canucks were interested in him in the past.

Edited by PositionOfPower
Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, Gnarcore said:

The talk after was he always tried to fleece other teams and got alienated. Not sure how accurate that is. 

He was an outcast in the GM community. No one wanted to deal with him, refs had bias against us also, rest of Canada hated us. 

 

GET SOMEONE NEW stop recycling the past cr*p.

  • Cheers 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, NUCKER67 said:

Looking at Gillis' drafts in VAN, he only had a Top 10 pick twice.  

 

Cody Hodgson and Bo Horvat

 

The rest of his 1st rounders were #22, #29 and #26.  Not really going to get an amazing player there. Sure, Benning got a good one in Boeser.

 

Gillis never had the high picks Benning had, though.  

Where did Hogz Gaudette, Gadjovich, Forsling come from then?

 

Hmm Demko too

 

All not first rounders but playing in NHL

Edited by PositionOfPower
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, aGENT said:

Don't forget Boeser.

 

The "no high picks" excuse is lame.

Yes under Gillis we never found a later 1st round gem or a later round gem no one graduated from the draft to becoming NHLers either for our team or another team. 

 

If we want more Jensens Gaunces Sauves Hogdsons Ellingtons please get Gillis.

Edited by PositionOfPower
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, PositionOfPower said:

Yes under Gillis we never found a later 1st round gem or a later round gem no one graduated from the draft to becoming NHLers either for our team or another team. 

 

If we want more Jensens Gaunces Sauves Hogdsons Ellingtons please get Gillis.

I do think if Gillis returns its President or bust, never GM again. I still think it's highly remote % he does return. When you do look at the leaked powerpoint for the Pittsburgh POHO job, shared that he did realize his weakness of drafting and showed a team/assistants to actually manage that player dev/drafting aspect more closely...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Has anyone talked about Dean Lombardi being a GM again. I know he works for Flyers but Aquaman should get him and have stan smyl as the POHO. I think Dean Lombardi is the type of GM that can put the finishing touches and he has won 2 cups with Kings already so he does have that pedigree. He is probably the most qualified for our GM job and has the best resume out there when looking at current GMs available

 

  • Vintage 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, NHL97OneTimer said:

Benning picks up good players in rounds 2 and up though.....Gillis was a disaster at the draft.  

 

I'm a bit forgetful here, but I'm recalling Gilman doing the contract signings, the draft being hopeless and a couple of trades working out.  What exactly do people remember Gillis doing that made him a decent GM?  Is it that the team was good then and so it's attributed to him and not his predecessor who built most of the team?  Serious question.

Brought in sleep doctors, Erhoff and an oxygen chamber, and was good at keeping contracts down - and with all that saved money, blew the entire wad in two players that's got bought out, and in today's money would cost over 6 million each.. in Booth and Ballard.   Didn't trade many high picks and got a better high pick back for Schneider...a trade many hated at the time but obviously was his one and only golden moment - other then of course the sleep doctors and Erhoff.   And if anyone brings up Sundin  - it's the most ridiculous contract ever.  

Edited by IBatch
  • Cheers 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...