Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

smithers joe

Members
  • Posts

    9,728
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Status Updates posted by smithers joe

  1. according to top shelf hockey podcast, newyork islanders are showing interest in a horvat trade.

    he suggested bailey to make the money work, a first and maybe a guy like dufour. bailey has 2 years at 5 mil left but is owed 3.5 mil

    1. Show previous comments  3 more
    2. smithers joe

      smithers joe

      this is not my proposal. i want to keep BO. i would want no less than a top 4 rd as part of a package and would prefer it was JT moved instead. it is all about what teams are willing to give up in a trade.

    3. Nucker 67

      Nucker 67

      Just saw this article at MyHockeyNow saying the same thing https://nyihockeynow.com/new-york-islanders-bo-hovat-vancouver-canucks-trade-rumors-lamoriello-alvvin/

       

      Their suggestion wouldn't be a good return at all, and thinking it has to be at a minimum:

      Horvat for Mayfield, Raty and a 2nd.  Maybe VAN retains some of Bo's salary this season.

    4. Coconuts

      Coconuts

      Bailey hasn't played very well and center's aren't their issue, but they could slot one over to the wing. What the Isles need is a scoring infusion on the wing, maybe Miller? 

       

      I do think they'd be a good trading partner, they're playing good hockey and that core of theirs isn't getting any younger. Either Miller or Horvat could be the sort of player they add to try and go on a few runs. 

  2. what canuck players would you place on waivers?

    1. JM_

      JM_

      would have been Dickinson. 

       

      I would waive Pearson and see what shakes. 

    2. Alflives

      Alflives

      If we’re claiming Jost then I’d put Stillman on waivers. 

    3. Ghostsof1915

      Ghostsof1915

      Pearson should get you something at the trade deadline. Even a 4th round pick. He's perfect for the playoffs. Stillman should be sent to Abbotsford and work on his game. He's terrible. 

  3. should mogilny go into the ring of honour?

    1. Show previous comments  3 more
    2. Coconuts

      Coconuts

      Hmm, Bieksa was around a bit longer than Salo but it's a fair question. Maybe Bieksa's more of a maybe too. It's tough to say where the line is. 

       

      The only guy I'd say is a slam dunk at this point is Edler, I dunno how they don't get Edler in there. He was here longer than Ohlund and holds many Canuck records for D. 

    3. Chickenspear

      Chickenspear

      Eddy, for sure should be in, and I'd also say Juice should be in the ring above Kes and Salo. Can't really find the words to explain it, but he's made more of a longstanding impact for me than 17 and 6, plus he signed the 1 day to retire a Canuck. He's never really left the city.

       

      I wouldn't be surprised if they signed Eddy to a 1 day when he's finally ready to hang them up. Maybe they go in the ring together.

    4. NewbieCanuckFan

      NewbieCanuckFan

      @Ghostsof1915  Not his fault either accepting that offer sheet from Booby Clarke as well but it left the team in a bit of a bind.  *HOWEVER* Kesler never just 'mailed it in' on games so it's a tough call from my POV.

  4. are our wingers good enough?

    1. Show previous comments  3 more
    2. luckylager

      luckylager

      No. 10 years of retool and we have a garbage team.

      It's over Joe. 

      Tell Aqua it's time

    3. J-23
    4. Elias Pettersson

      Elias Pettersson

      Miller and Kuzmenko are legit.  Mikheyev is also legit but can't be relied on as a top 6 winger every night. Boeser is too slow and Garland is too small.  Podkolzin and Hoglander are still not fully developed so still have question marks.  Pearson is a 3rd liner and will be gone after next year.  We do have Klimovich, Karlsson, Lekkerimaki and McDonough waiting in the wings so we have lots of youth coming up.  So I would concentrate on getting more centres, especially if BO is gone.

  5. i think 650 should hire jannek hanson to work with dodd on canuck's hour. then bring drance on for 5 minutes to tell all he knows. annoying voice and know-it-all air.

  6. is this JR's way of saying,.. shh, we're tanking quietly.

    1. Show previous comments  2 more
    2. chon derry

      chon derry

       Sabres aren’t doin to good lately. It’s pretty sludgy for either team. Win or lose.  Both teams swirling around the bottom of the barrel. 

    3. King Heffy

      King Heffy

      I think the hiring of Yeo indicted that winning wasn't a priority.

    4. chon derry

      chon derry

      @King HeffyI’m really starting to think yeo is the problem. One would think the players would try as hard as possible to avoid the possibility of him stepping in. But I lean towards Rutherfords comment of already having to continue to pay for green and the what’s left of BBs contract. Add a 3rd coach’s salary. Doesn’t make to much sense, a new coach isn’t going to magically change this train wreck. Ride BB out I’m sure by the end of it he’ll want out anyway. 

  7. any team that tanks on purpose shouldn't be able bto draft first or second.

    1. Show previous comments  2 more
    2. King Heffy

      King Heffy

      Where do you draw the line if that's your definition?

    3. Ghostsof1915

      Ghostsof1915

      Tell that to Toronto and Edmonton.

    4. spook007

      spook007

      That's just it, where do you draw the line?

      Who decides, when to change direction of your club. and needing new players?

       

      I agree, it shouldn't be allowed but din't think you can administrate it...

  8. moving under performing contracts, miller, boeser, pearson, OEL,myers and poolman is nearly impossible but they must try.

    1. NewbieCanuckFan

      NewbieCanuckFan

      All those bad contracts that Mike Gillis saddled JR with.:P

  9. thank you B.C. lions for your season and efforts against the bombers. you did B.C. proud.

    1.  johngould21

      johngould21

      Rourke got many fans excited about the CFL again, especially some younger ones.

    2. Bell

      Bell

      Bombers offensive and defensive lines were way to big and strong for the Lions.  Rourke is the best thing to happen in the CFL in a long long time.  Wonder if an NFL team takes a run at him in the offseason.

       

  10. i liked the effort against the bruins. they are just a better team

    i was entertained.

  11. i'ld like to hear JR or PA come out and say, we know what the problem is, but be patient, we're working to change things around. i could live with that. could you?

    1. Alflives

      Alflives

      Totally agree Joe.  We need a clearly stated plan and direction.  Would be great if our owner and JR held a presser where JR stated the plan and our owner openly supported it.  

    2. Solinar

      Solinar

      Give it 10 more games, and if we continue this trend, our season is officially done.  Just looked at capfriendly, and buying out pearson and poolman actually makes sense.  you end up saving a few million in cap space tho with poolman, you'd basically get the same just sending him to play in the minors and not having the double term caphit.  Myers isn't worth it, but you could retain 3 million and he's a trade chip again.  Worth it for one year.  OEL, we're stuck with barring him actually retiring.  Yet another Swede who has a retirement contract in vancouver, much like eriksson.  You eat that and try mitigate the damage with his ...intangibles playing in the press box or 3rd pairing.  We're now 3 years away from anything worth mentioning because of Jim Bennings terrible trade.  I'd look squarely at ownership for that.  There are no shortcuts, only death by a thousand paper cuts with the way this team has been managed.

  12. new name... one period a game canucks.....i'm a one period fan, now i guess. where did my canucks go?

    1. -Vintage Canuck-

      -Vintage Canuck-

      The Canucks “team” disappeared. Now we’re left with Canucks “individuals”.

  13. has JR done anything yet?

    1. Show previous comments  8 more
    2. Coconuts

      Coconuts

      He threw a dart as his Boudreau dartboard 

    3. smithers joe

      smithers joe

      wake me when he figures out what's wrong with this team and does something about it.

    4. Tre Mac

      Tre Mac

      We need a president that can oversee a rebuild, he's simply the wrong fit but that seems to be inline with ownerships dysfunction.  Wrong fits everywhere.

  14. i'll have respect for management when instead of saying what is wrong with the team, they actually do something to fix it. if it's the coaches, let them go, if its the make up of the team, change it.

    if it's ownership, put the blame at their feet.

    1. Alflives

      Alflives

      Yup.  I think we have some excellent players, but need to play a lot smarter, especially when Demko is struggling.  

    2. Ghostsof1915

      Ghostsof1915

      Time for action.

    3. spook007

      spook007

      Spot on...

      Talk is cheap. Throwing coaches under the bus in public is pathetic. 

      A lot of talk has been done, and it looks like they are clueless, changing direction every 6 months. 

  15. after their poor start, i started asking everytime they got the puck,what are you going to do with it? answer was always, give it to montreal. i fell asleep when it was 4 0. don't know if they played better in the,3rd. hard to watch.

    1. spook007

      spook007

      They did, or maybe Montreal took the foot of the gas...

       

      Really disappointing showing...

  16. has seattle a better selection of players than we have? they are sure playing better. do they have a better system?

    1. Curmudgeon

      Curmudgeon

      Many of us (me included) snickered when Ron Francis and his staff selected a flock of nobodies in expansion. Going into season two of their existence, 14 players taken in the expansion draft are on the Seattle roster. Seattle did a particularly good job drafting defencemen, with six of their top seven taken at expansion. Vegas, on the other hand has only four original draftees, preferring instead to trade and sign marquee guys. So Vegas is all flash and dazzle while Seattle is quietly building a competitive team and looking to build through the draft (they have ALL of their draft picks for the next three years, plus six more they've acquired through trades). 

       

      But to answer your question, no, Seattle doesn't have a better selection of players, but they have 23 guys committed to pulling in the same direction and believing in what their coach is telling them. So does Vancouver but they haven't put all the pieces together yet. Vegas may win more over the next couple of years, but Seattle looks to be in it for the long haul.

    2. chon derry

      chon derry

      Seattle had 31 GMs helping them. Vancouver right now has 32 GMs working against us 

  17. not advocating a tank, but how would this line up look with bedard in the line up?

    1. Show previous comments  1 more
    2. Coconuts

      Coconuts

      Like one that gives me hope 

    3. Bruce Boudreau
    4. PunjabiCanucks

      PunjabiCanucks

      Depends because then you sell assets hard for Defence help

  18. we've given you mikheyev, joshua, lazar, studnika, stillman and bear, bruce we should be stanley cup bound? we've given you everthing.

    does JR speak for all the management staff?

    1. lmm

      lmm

      jim needs to go

      we need 0 years more of his tripe

  19. what does each center, petey, horvat and miller need in their winger's skills that enable them to be the most successful. JR said that this team has the wrong mix of players. are the wingers we have hindering the center's play?

    1. lmm

      lmm

      Horvat needs Miller

      Petey needs a digger

      Miller needs 1 passer and 1 shooter both with speed and size

  20. speaking of snow, 2nd day of it in smithers. time to put  my scooter

    away for the winter.

    1. hammertime

      hammertime

      I put my scooter awayyyyyy! 

    2. JM_

      JM_

      thinking of checking out the skiing in Smithers this year, whats the road like up there from Vancouver in winter? 

  21. if they could move miller, myers and boeser and draft bedard, then go from there. our cap would allow us to trade for good wingers and defensemen. that would be my rebuild.

    1. Show previous comments  4 more
    2. NewbieCanuckFan

      NewbieCanuckFan

      Johnson *MIGHT* have value at the trading deadline mainly because his contract ends this season.  Boeser *ONLY* thing of value is that he's not old.  He's injury-prone & being paid for what he might do (rather what he's done).  Has nothing to do with not thinking outside the box.  A shame really because he's a real stand-up guy.  Solid character.  Unfortunately that doesn't help any professional hockey team in the wins/losses because if he's not scoring, he's useless on the ice imho.

    3. Bad_BOI_pete

      Bad_BOI_pete

      well, color me clueless? :bigblush:

    4. NewbieCanuckFan

      NewbieCanuckFan

      @Petey_BOI  nah, heck we can *BOTH* be wrong.:P

       

      We'll just have to agree to disagree.:)

  22. ff we could fix our defense and draft bedard, would we be a contender?

  23. who skates with bedard?

    c 2nd line?

    1. Show previous comments  3 more
    2. smithers joe

      smithers joe

      how about pettersson and podkolzin.?

    3. smithers joe

      smithers joe

      mcdonough 3rd line center

      miller traded at deadline for a good d-man, a pick and a d-man prospect.

      would this be a good start for a rebuild?

    4. luckylager

      luckylager

      Hopefully miller is gone by then and we have some random NPCs skating with Bedard while the team rebuilds properly.

  24. i just noticed that seattle beat buffalo 5 to 1. might not be a gimme like last year.

  25. i don't know what it would take but i'ld love to get grans from LA and mukhamadullin from NJ. future d-men in this league.

    1. chon derry

      chon derry

      I could see the jersey play by play announcers being happy about not having to pronounce second guys name especially with the joisey accent. :lol:

    2. smithers joe

      smithers joe

      i don't know how good they will be in the nhl but our pool of defensemen isn't very good. prospects closer to playing is better than waiting 5 years for them to play. any young rupert boys that can play defense?

    3. chon derry

      chon derry

      There is a young goalie playin college  back east from here. 

×
×
  • Create New...